How to negotiate when a seller insists on keeping specific appliances
When a seller insists on keeping specific appliances, it's often a minor point but can become a deal breaker if not handled right. Focus on understanding the item's value to him or her versus its cost to you to replace or deduct.
November 15, 2026 · 4 min read
Assess the actual value of the items
Before you react, quickly calculate the cost to replace the appliances he or she wants to take. Is it an old, mismatched refrigerator, or a brand-new, built-in professional range? The value of a standard washer and dryer might be a few hundred dollars, while a high-end kitchen package could run into thousands.
Consider the impact on your after-repair value (ARV) if the property is missing key appliances. For a flip, you'll likely be installing new ones anyway. For a rental, you'll need them. This quick assessment helps you decide how much this concession is truly worth to you.
Understand the seller's attachment
Sometimes, it is not about the monetary value but the sentimental value. A seller might have received a specific appliance as a gift, or it might be the only item he or she is taking to his or her new home. Ask him or her why those specific items are important.
A simple question like, "Is there a particular reason you want to keep those appliances?" can open up a conversation. Understanding his or her perspective allows you to frame your response more empathetically and find a solution that works for both of you.
Options for concession: monetary vs. physical
You have two main ways to handle this. You can let him or her take the items, or you can offer a small credit or price reduction in exchange for him or her leaving them. If the items are low value and easy to replace, letting him or her take them might be the simplest path to a signed contract.
If the items are valuable, or if removing them would cause damage (like a built-in oven), a monetary concession might be better. Suppose a seller wants to take a $1,000 refrigerator. You could reduce your offer by $500, making it a win-win. This is not legal advice, so consult with a legal professional for exact phrasing in your contract.
Clearly define what stays and what goes in the contract
Whatever you decide, make sure it is explicitly stated in the purchase agreement. Do not rely on verbal agreements. List every appliance by type and location (e.g., "refrigerator in kitchen," "washer and dryer in laundry room") and specify whether it is included or excluded from the sale.
This prevents misunderstandings and disputes at closing or during the final walkthrough. A clear contract protects both you and the seller. This small detail can prevent a big headache later on.
When to use this as a minor concession for a larger gain
This is often a perfect opportunity for a small concession that can yield a larger benefit. If a seller is digging his or her heels in on price or another term, agreeing to let him or her take a specific appliance might be the "yes" he or she needs to feel heard.
Use it strategically. For example, if he or she is asking for an extra week to move out, you might say, "If we can agree on the closing date, then yes, you can certainly take the washing machine." It's about finding small wins to move the overall deal forward. Do not just give it away without trying to get something in return.
What to do if the item is built-in
Built-in appliances (like dishwashers, double ovens, or sometimes even refrigerators that are custom-fitted) present a different challenge. Removing these can cause damage to cabinetry or countertops, which adds to your repair costs. Make sure you understand if the item is truly built-in.
If the seller insists on taking a built-in item, you must factor in the cost of repair and replacement into your offer. It might be better to insist that built-ins remain or offer a significant concession to keep him or her from taking it, especially if the damage will be substantial. Document any agreed-upon removal and repair responsibilities in the contract.
Questions people ask
What if it's the washer and dryer?
Washers and dryers are often important to sellers, and replacing them is usually straightforward. You can often agree to let him or her take them or offer a small credit, depending on his or her motivation and the overall deal.
Should I just say 'yes' to keep the deal moving?
If the items are low value and will not cause damage upon removal, saying 'yes' can be a quick way to build rapport and keep the negotiation smooth. Always weigh the cost of the concession against the value of getting the contract signed.
How do I put this in the contract?
In your purchase agreement, you will typically find a section for personal property. Clearly list which specific appliances are included in the sale and which are excluded. Be precise to avoid any ambiguity.
Go deeper
More from the desk
Every lead on Speed to Seller is a seller who already replied to a text. $5 each, sold once, to one buyer.